robotic hand touching ipad

The Story Behind Jack Williamson’s With Folded Hands

This is the next blog in the “What Was the Author Thinking” series─researching into the backstory of dystopian and frightening tales as is fitting this time of the year with Halloween around the corner.

In this blog, we take up “With Folded Hands” a novelette written in 1947 by the Grand Master of Science Fiction, Jack Williamson. And, as with other authors in this series, Stephen King, Ray Bradbury and Philip K. Dick, Jack Williamson also had a connection with L. Ron Hubbard’s horror story, Fear, as covered later.

About the Story

July 1947 issue of Astounding Science Fiction

July 1947 issue of Astounding Science Fiction

Despite the seemingly innocent title, the story portrays a chilling dystopian future in which robots—referred to as Humanoids—are equipped with advanced AI and remorseless adhere to their mission which is “To Serve and Obey, and Guard Men from Harm,” even when it is not in the best interests of the population at large.

The story was originally published in the July 1947 issue of Astounding Science Fiction and later adapted for the NBC radio series, Dimension X. In 1949, Williamson expanded it into a full-length novel entitled, The Humanoids.

The title and final image of the story illustrate the futility of fighting back against the Humanoids. According to various resources, folded hands are a symbol of obedience, submission, sincerity, and repentance. The history of the gesture traces back to the Greeks. In the book, A History of Ancient Sculpture, clasped hands were looked upon as a hindrance to progress and good fortune, and a token for trouble. For the Romans, hands held together meant surrender, which is certainly the case for the protagonist at the end of Williamson’s novelette.

The Backstory

Jack Williamson spent the first three years of his life on a ranch at the top of the Sierra Madre Mountains on the Yaqui River in Sonora, Mexico. He grew up on a farm in New Mexico and though he wanted to be a scientist, he didn’t have the funds for an education in that field. So, instead, he took up writing science fiction and sold his first story, “The Metal Man” at the age of 20.

In a 1991 interview, Williamson talks about his childhood and how it, along with later technological advances, helped shape his story. “I wrote ‘With Folded Hands’ immediately after World War II when the shadow of the atomic bomb had just fallen over SF and was beginning to haunt the imaginations of people in the US. The story grows out of that general feeling that some of the technological creations we had developed with the best intentions might have disastrous consequences in the long run.”

As for the emotional reach of the story, Williamson attributed this to “my own early childhood, when people were attempting to protect me from all those hazardous things a kid is going to encounter in the isolated frontier setting I grew up in.”

Quotes From the Story

As the saying goes, “A picture is worth a thousand words,” however, for a writer, words can create unforgettable images in the reader’s mind as in this excerpt from the story:

“What is the matter, Mr. Underhill?” The alert mechanical must have perceived his shuddering illness. “Are you unwell?”

“No, there’s nothing the matter with me,” he gasped desperately. “I’ve just found out that I’m perfectly happy, under the Prime Directive. Everything is absolutely wonderful.” His voice came dry and hoarse and wild. “You won’t have to operate on me.”

And as the Dean of Science Fiction Jack Williamson described it, it is about when “the best possible machines, designed with the best of intentions, become the ultimate horror.”

The Link to Fear

Ray Bradbury, A.E. Van Vogt and Jack Williamson

Ray Bradbury, A.E. Van Vogt and Jack Williamson at the first Writers of the Future Awards ceremony

And what is the link to L. Ron Hubbard’s Fear?

Williamson knew L. Ron Hubbard and read his stories as they came out, including Fear which he called, “The triumphant pioneer of psychological thrillers.”

In addition to knowing the author, there is yet another link. When L. Ron Hubbard established the Writers of the Future Contest in 1983 to help new authors get a start with their career, Jack Williamson stepped on board as a judge along with fellow sci-fi and fantasy luminaries Algis Budrys, Frank Herbert, Anne McCaffrey, Larry Niven and Robert Silverberg. Williamson also attended the first Writers of the Future Workshop held in Taos, New Mexico as an instructor. He would go on to serve as both judge and mentor for the Writers of the Future Contest for another two decades until he passed away in 2006 at the age of 98.

In acknowledgment of his work in the field of science fiction as both an author and educator, Jack was awarded the L. Ron Hubbard Lifetime Achievement Award for Outstanding Contributions to the Arts.

You can read his original story, “With Folded Hands,” as it was published in Astounding Science Fiction or get it through Amazon Kindle.

2 replies
  1. MAJ Richard Centner, Army, ret.
    MAJ Richard Centner, Army, ret. says:

    I got to know Jack Williamson when I lived in Clovis, New Mexico, just a few miles north of Portales where he was a professor. I visited with him at the drugstore fountain a couple of doors down from his wife’s store (children’s clothing, if memory serves). I was struck by his generosity of time, advice and memories with a young, small town radio reporter.
    He entertained my questions, and especially enjoyed discussing SF old or new. “With Folded Hands” led to probably our most spirited discussion. As a libertarian-leaning Conservative, I told him I consider it the most eloquent portrayal in SF of the danger of what C.S. Lewis called a tyranny with good intentions. He seemed shocked and said, “That’s not it at all.” It’s about the danger of misused technology. I replied that the plot certainly made that clear but suggested the political implications seemed obvious. As a Liberal, in the best sense, he resisted that interpretation. Thinking back, I believe he might apply his point to some of the excesses of today’s social media. Perhaps he considered abusing tools of progress a greater danger than abuse of political power in the US. Although he sent me a couple of encouraging notes when I was earning a master’s, I never got to revisit the topic with him. I thought Nixon and LBJ might have made him more sympathetic to my interpretation. In any case, this fine work remains one of my favorite science fiction tales of all time. Now 75, I see very few that match it.

    • John Goodwin
      John Goodwin says:

      Thank you for your comments. Jack Williamson was indeed very generous in paying it forward to aspiring writers. I would see him at least once a year when he came out for the Writers of the Future Awards event. While I didn’t get into politics with him — don’t do it with any of the judges actually — I do have one story with Jack that I would like to share. We were guests of a Shuttle Launch at Cape Kennedy. During the actual shuttle launch, all the judges and winners were at a set of bleachers a mile away somewhere in the swamps (signs said stay away from the edge of the river because of snakes and alligators). Jack was probably in his early 80s then and he was just like a little kid. Having written about space and rockets since the 1920s, he had never himself witnessed a rocket launch. Just watching him watching the launch almost made the whole experience worth it. – John Goodwin


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Another article you may be interested in: Sci-Fi Robots